great album
author: Jim Skypeck
This was a great surprise as I'd never heard of James before discovering his album here on CDBaby. His choice of material is wonderful and anyone who pulls off "My Simple Christmas Wish" gets kudos from me. I love his interpretation of the songs and hope he will consider another album in the future.
Read more...
What More Can I Say?
author: Scott Whiteley Carter
James sings some of my favorite songs -- which can be a dangerous thing to do. I know how I want them to sound. James does justice to all of the songs on this CD. There is not a throwaway track.
"Finishing the Hat" is one of my favorite songs, but does usually work outside of the show. James transforms it into a stand alone song.
Not only does he perform my favorite songs well, but he is making me re-examine my thoughts about other songs. "The Spark of Creation," "Sweet Liberty," and "You'll Never Walk Alone" are often sung so overly-earnestly that I want to run from the room screaming. James finds simplicity and subtlety in these songs. He really tries to serve the songs and the composers, not himself.
This will have a lot of playtime in my cd player.
Read more...
Eclectic and Sensitive
author: Paul G.
James Donegan's elegant tenor wraps itself around an eclectic mix of lesser known musical theatre songs. The pieces showcase a sensitive performer who gives sensitive renderings of all the songs, while staying true to the context of the music. In the midst of beautiful ballads, you get the deliciously wicked and wry "My Simple Christmas Wish", which is a favorite of cabaret performers. My personal favorites are Stephen Sondheim's "Finishing the Hat" from 'Sunday in the Park With George', a song about being true to your life, your love, and your art, and "A Breeze Off The River" from 'The Full Monty', about a father's often unexpressed love for his child. The album closes with Rodgers and Hammerstein's "You'll Never Walk Alone" from 'Carousel', and Donegan gives it a spritual touch, without going for over the top vocal theatrics. A well done, thought out album.
Read more...