Stellar performances
author: Mark Anderson
The concept, performances, and dedication that went in to this recording makes it a must have for those of us who like a taste of the avante garde. However, this might be fairly difficult music for the average listener. Not exactly tuneful. Let's say you probably won't be whistling these tunes while puttering around the garden.
Read more...
Tom Lewis and Phil Hey are truly a great rhythm team. “Out To Lunch” has a certa
author: JazzIprov Magazine
By Dan Bilawsky
While it might be considered a bit of jazz heresy, I have to start things off by admitting that I have never been drawn in by the majority of the songs on Eric Dolphy’s Out To Lunch. I have never completely understood why, since all of the musicians on the album are favorites of mine and I have fairly eclectic and adventurous tastes. It certainly puts me in the minority of jazz writers who don’t love this album. Out To Lunch is considered to be a cornerstone of the “new” jazz, which isn’t so new several decades later. It is seen by many as Dolphy’s masterpiece. Despite many attempts to re-explore this album, I have always been slightly put off by a lot of the music, with “Gazzelloni” and “Straight Up And Down” being the two exceptions. Looking beyond these initial statements, I must say that I’ve always been enamored by Dolphy’s playing and skills, as a multi-instrumentalist, and enjoyed many other recordings that he worked on. I have a deep respect for his compositional skills and adventurous spirit. A recording like Live At The Artists’ Quarter showcases the works from this album, with a few other Dolphy tunes and one original thrown into the set. The Out To Lunch Quintet, to their credit, manage to stay fairly loyal to Dolphy’s musical creations and, surprisingly given my previous attempts to really dig into Out To Lunch, draw me into the music and give me a real appreciation for these songs. The little things really help the music to take on a different shape. “Hat and Beard” swings a bit more, and isn’t as militaristic, during this interpretation. The slightly looser and more organic feel, created by Tom Lewis on bass and Phil Hey on drums, makes all the difference. The original recording of “Something Sweet, Something Tender” was a bit darker and moodier than the interpretation on this album. Dave Milne, who does an excellent job in the Eric Dolphy role on the album, has a thinner tone than Dolphy, and Tom Lewis doesn’t make things as stormy as Richard Davis did. The tone of the record, while nailing all of the songs, is a bit brighter than the original work. This might be why I am more inclined to listen to these Dolphy interpretations than the originals.
I could spend this entire review comparing the old and the new, but I am more inclined to speak about the specific merits that come from this live recording. “Gazzelloni” is one of the catchiest songs on the album, and Milne’s flute and Kelly Rossum’s trumpet work well together here. Dave Hagedorn does a great job gelling with Lewis and emphasizing the harmonic make-up of the piece. Tom Lewis and Phil Hey are truly a great rhythm team. “Out To Lunch” has a certain buoyancy, provided by this duo, which helps to lift the rest of the ensemble. Rossum’s energetic, punchy trumpet work, mid-track, is smile inducing. Hey has an opportunity to stretch out near the end of this one and he makes good use of his solo space. The quirky melody of “Straight Up And Down,” which opens and closes the tune, is handled very well. “Far Cry” makes one automatically think of Dolphy’s association with Booker Little, and it’s nice to hear Rossum, in the Little role, stretching out a bit. Milne builds things up to a frenzy during his solo and keeps the energy high. Hagedorn’s unaccompanied vibraphone solo is wonderfully eerie and the whole band joins in after to finish the song. “The Prophet” has received treatments from Terence Blanchard, Oliver Lake, Andrew Cyrille and several other first-rate musicians. This quintet acquits itself well on what is one of the more conventional Dolphy tunes on the CD. Rossum’s “Rush Hour,” which is the only original on the album, features some great vibes soloing from Hagedorn. This up-tempo burner is complete with horn and fire engine noises to simulate the sounds of a real rush hour commute. It sounds, compositionally speaking, like a cross between Dolphy and Ornette Coleman. The Out To Lunch Quintet should be applauded for their outstanding interpretations of Eric Dolphy’s work and they certainly opened my ears to some of this classic material.
Read more...
Everybody sounds
idiomatic and on occasion inspired. It’s all good.
author: Grego Applegate Edwards, Cadence Magazine
"... trumpet, sax and vibes collectively solo in and out of time with the rhythm section commenting on the intervallic relations in the tune and with each other, a fast tumbler with a three way dialogue, or five if you like. ... played with connoisseur’s attention to detail."
- Grego Applegate Edwards, Cadence Magazine, www.cadencebuilding.com
Read more...
appeals to Dolphy's would-be masses
author: Chris Riemenschneider, Minneapolis Star Tribune
Unlike a lot of projects in which jazz diehards get together to pay tribute to a relatively obscure legend, the all-star local ensemble that performed Coltrane peer Eric Dolphy's most celebrated album at the AQ in June didn't geek out with their arrangements or turn to the avant-garde. This eight-song collection (including one original by Kelly Rossum) appeals to Dolphy's would-be masses with a wistful and elegant set anchored by David Milne's reed work and Dave Hagedorn's ear-candy vibes.
Read more...