I really love this CD!
author: Jon
AHHH, yes! This CD is brilliant! I really love this band, each song on here really seems to flow nicely together. I don't hear each song separately, I hear the whole cd as an idea. Don't get me wrong, 'tis not a concept album. Just very nice. I always like to listen to it when I'm feeling rather melancholic. It's not emo, but it fits that mood.
Read more...
An amazing counter to the retro-synth that is infecting indie rock.
author: Tom Staddon, Editor, Rex Efex Magazine
Right now, the state of indie-rock is wierd. On one side, you have the plethora of Death Cab rip offs and on the other you have the "new is old" mantra of the new-wave revival Franz Ferdinand rip offs. The primary concept here is "rip off."
The Seldon Plan's "Making Circles" is nowhere near this mess. They are carving out a sound on this record that is firmly rooted in Promise Ringesque angluar hooks, but have the solid rock qualities of a Teenage Fanclub or Frank Black's post-Pixies work. The record as whole is strong and subtle, with each song building on one another as if telling a story. Songs like "Westchester" backed by others like "Holding Patterns are Slow" suggest that this band may be the poster child for a new genre of indie rock: AOIR (album-oriented-indie-rock).
One listen to this record and you will see that not only do these guys obviously listen to good music, they make it too.
Read more...
a well-crafted record from start to finish
author: A. S.
These guys don't get the respect they deserve here in Baltimore; They're truly one of the only bands in town who aren't just kicking around playing shows, but instead are making great RECORDS. This is a well-crafted record from start to finish, a whole greater than the sum of its parts. The songs are simple but the subtle hooks stick with you. And what sticks with me most when the record's over is the journey I've been led on -- the squall of guitar noise and cascading drums at the end of album-closer "Chicago 2003" feels not just cathartic after the more restrained pop that precedes it, but earned.
Read more...
Amazing, delicate, and intricate intelligent indie rock! A must have for those i
author: Jake Ramsay
Making Circles is a simple delight. The songs on this disk are a fine example of mid-tempo inteliigent indie pop for those with discriminating taste. Songs like the title track "Making Circles" and the downtempo "Samuel P. Huntingdon" recall early REM and and early Cure, while the overall sound of this disc is closer to the latest efforts by Spoon mixed with the energy and tone of the record "Proximity Effect" by Nada Surf. This record recals a time in music when it was OK to make your lyrics somewhat intellectual and your pop catchy and complex. This is a great CD by a great band.
Read more...